The Hidden Costs of Underutilized Fleet Vehicles — and How to Spot Them
For many government agencies, universities, and utilities, vehicles are a necessary investment. But here’s the truth: a surprising percentage of fleet vehicles sit idle most of the time.
Underutilization isn’t just wasteful—it’s expensive. Every unused vehicle adds unnecessary costs for fuel, insurance, depreciation, and maintenance. Worse, it ties up budget dollars that could be used elsewhere.
The good news? With the right data and processes, you can identify underutilized vehicles and reclaim those costs.
What Does Underutilization Look Like?
A vehicle is considered underutilized if it’s used significantly less than peers of the same class or below your organization’s threshold (e.g., 30% usage).
Common signs include:
-
Vehicles averaging fewer than 200–300 miles per month
-
Repeated “no-shows” or canceled reservations
-
Department-assigned vehicles that rarely leave the lot
-
Seasonal peaks with long periods of downtime
The Hidden Costs of Keeping Idle Vehicles
Even when parked, vehicles cost money. Underutilized vehicles bring hidden expenses such as:
-
Depreciation: Every unused car still loses value year over year.
-
Insurance premiums: Insurers don’t adjust for idle vehicles.
-
Maintenance: Low use often leads to neglected preventative maintenance and higher repair costs later.
-
Opportunity cost: Money tied up in idle assets could fund EVs, tech upgrades, or staffing.
How to Spot Underutilized Vehicles
✅ Track Utilization Metrics
Use motor pool software to track:
-
Miles driven
-
Reservation frequency
-
Hours in use vs. parked
✅ Benchmark Across Departments
Compare usage rates by site or department to highlight outliers.
✅ Run Heat Maps of Demand
See when vehicles are most needed. Often, fewer vehicles can cover demand if scheduling is automated.
✅ Audit Assigned Vehicles
Challenge departments that hold vehicles “just in case.” Many times, a shared pool serves them better.
What to Do With Underutilized Vehicles
-
Reallocate: Move low-use vehicles to high-demand sites.
-
Right-size: Reduce fleet size based on actual data.
-
Repurpose: Transition underutilized sedans or vans for training or backup.
-
Retire/Sell: Free up capital for new technology or EV investment.
Case in Point
A county fleet running 400+ vehicles found that nearly 20% of its sedans were used less than once per week. By right-sizing the fleet and reallocating assets, they reduced annual costs by hundreds of thousands of dollars while improving overall vehicle availability.
The Bottom Line
Idle vehicles quietly drain public-sector budgets. By tracking utilization, comparing across sites, and making data-driven adjustments, your organization can eliminate waste while improving service.
Helen Lagerblade
